Bruins Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: Soriano Belts Three, Cubs Snap Slide Bar-right-arrows



Rivalries That Aren't, But Should Be

With the bowl games (that matter) still a ways off, I thought I'd mention something I've been musing about:  college football rivalries.  

Sure, we all know the traditional ones, like Alabama/Auburn, OSU/Michigan, Oklahoma/Texas, Army/Navy, Texas/Texas A&M, Florida/Georgia, Miami/Florida St., Nebraska/Oklahoma, Auburn/Georgia, Harvard/Yale, California/Stanford, and, of course, the one that gets my vote for greatest rivalry:  UCLA/USC.

But, why are these rivalries, well, rivalries?  Sure, we all know the obvious answers.  Many of these teams share conferences, states, cities or long and storied histories.  And those reasons are as good as any, I suppose.  I also recognize that, with conference play, many schools don't have the flexibility in their schedules to add many new rivalries.

Nevertheless, just for fun, I wonder what rivalries make the "most sense," if all these factors disappeared and we had it to do it all over again.  What if we just looked at the universities, their students and their recent pasts, and spun a new set of traditions out of whole cloth?  What are the "natural" rivalries?  Or, in other words, what rivalries that aren't, but should be?  

Here's my list, in no particular order.  

1.  UCLA vs. Michigan.  What a great rivalry that would be.  Talk about a couple schools who reflect one another in so many ways.  Both are public institutions.  Each is a world renowned academic institution (with Michigan just edging UCLA in the most recent US News survey).  The Bruins and Wolverines also share top flight programs in their major revenue sports, though thanks to an apathetic administration and a certain coach, us Bruins can't exactly presume to say that our football team quite compares. (And, no, we are not hyping this as the best rivalry just because the Wolverines are coming into Pauley tomorrow afternoon for one of the most anticipated matchups of this OOC season.)

2.  Stanford vs. Duke.  These two universities are nothing less that two of the premier private academic institutions in the country (see here again).  And, when it comes to sports, these schools share great basketball teams who have made a home in the upper echelon of the sport for years.  Sure, the Trees have been down some since Monty left the 'ford, but if they can ever right the ship, I can see Stanford and Duke being great natural rivals.  And they share something else that makes them a great fit: some of the most desperately terrible football teams in the country.  

3.  Southern Cal vs. Miami.  The original gansta college football programs.  With Miami, you had the infamous programs of Dennis Erickson and Larry Coker, and a long string of scandals including one involving none other than 2 Live Crew.  At USC, Pete Carroll has his own long stretch of scandal and criminality, along with the stalwart support of Snoop Dog.  Tainted success.  Not sure what's in the water at these private universities, but there are synergies aplenty for a great rivalry.

4.  Texas vs. Florida.  Natural rivals.  These schools, with over 46,000 students apiece, are two of the five largest universities in the nation.  Both are public universities.  Each have exceptional major revenues sports programs, which have been in or just outside the rankings in both football and basketball recently.  Both play in BCS conferences (Big 12 and SEC).  Both are in the South, well, sorta, and enjoy similar climates on their Austin and Gainesville campuses (though Gainesville is more humid).  And, they even they share the exact same spot (47th) in the the most recent academic rankings to boot.  But, when it comes down to it, I'd just love to see them play each other more often.  And, yes, what I think is entirely enough, thank you, to justify this rivalry.

5.  Arizona vs. Kentucky.  Here we have two public universities with mediocre academic reputations that are nothing less than basketball crazy.  What these schools may lack in scholarly bonafides, they make up for in sheer hoops success and tradition (with Kentucky, of course, having the edge in that).  So, I propose a yearly trip between Tucson and Lexington to begin what might be a great college rivalry.

6.  Arizona State vs. LSU.  According to Playboy's most recent list of America's top party schools, Arizona State ranks No.1, with LSU coming in just behind in the No. 4 spot.  Both campuses also enjoy some of the best "talent" around, with ASU coming in at No. 2 on one recent list (UCLA is No. 2, I hasten to add), and LSU doing pretty well itself according to reliable sources (i.e., my jackass friends).  Sounds like a rivalry to me.  Or a least a really awesome tailgate/post-game party.

7.  California vs. North Carolina.  Although California may not have the same sports tradition as UNC, these two schools have one thing in common.  They both have hired solid football coaches, and have demonstrated a commitment to winning.  Would Jeff Tedford and Butch Davis turn these two historic public institutions into rivals on the gridiron?  Perhaps so.

8.  Northwestern vs. Vanderbilt.  Two more fine academic institutions, with long football histories. Long histories of mostly failure and futility, however.  Northwestern and Vanderbilt, playing football since 1876 and 1890, respectively, have had their fair share of lumps on the field.  Northwestern, though briefly No. 1 in 1936 and 1962, and with a blip in 1995, have spent most of its history in the cellar, currently in the bottom half of the Big Ten.  Likewise, Vanderbilt, with its last winning season was in 1982, has been getting kicked around the SEC for years.  Misery loves company they say.  So, we might have ourselves a rivalry.

9.  Washington vs. Wisconsin.  No shortage of success in the histories of these fine schools.  But, aside from the appeal of U'Dub v. U'Dub, what would this rivalry have to offer? Well, for one thing, you have two talented teams from dreary locales, who are in dire need of a natural tan.   And then you have the fact that both schools represent progressive corners of their respective states.  Maybe saying we'd have the battle of Seawood vs. Bratworst would be going a bit far, but we might have a nice rivalry.

What do you all think?  What have I missed?  Fire away in the comments section.

GO BRUINS.

0 recs | Comment 6 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Great post
Like each one of these.

by HornsFan on Dec 22, 2006 8:27 AM PST   0 recs

Cal and UNC...
...are also public universities.

by nafselon on Dec 22, 2006 1:30 PM PST   0 recs

Mental note
Don't hit the eggnog until Christmas.  Friday is too early.

At least I didn't call Texas, Texas A&M....

by Menelaus on Dec 22, 2006 2:32 PM PST to parent up   0 recs

3 More should-be rivalries
Arkansas vs. West Virginia...two schools located in areas that are dentally challenged, football teams both on the rise, basketball programs also improving.  Could be a great redneck rivalry...

Colorado vs. Oregon State...could be the "liberal bowl", both schools full of moonbat hippies, teams could play in birkenstocks...

Wyoming vs. Washington State...both campuses in the middle of absolutely nowhere

by bbuclabruins on Dec 22, 2006 2:04 PM PST   0 recs

ucla v. cal
I know it's a quasi-rivalry, but the ucla cal football game should have some sort of unique flair attached to it.  Where else are there two schools that are essentially the same university (university of california at berkeley and university of california at los angeles) that are each so competitive ... I like the idea of the "bear bowl" or something to give that game some extra special fanfare.
F-CK $c

by royobruin on Dec 22, 2006 2:07 PM PST   0 recs

Here's A Couple Of Others....

UCLA - Michigan is definitely one that should be.  In fact, it COULD have been one long ago had we made it to the Rose Bowl back in 1973.  I thought it WAS one beginning in 1982 when we beat them up there during the regular season and then beat them again on New Year's Day.  But here's a couple more that I think should be listed:
  1.  UCLA vs. LSU - The ultimate alphabet bowl.  It would be awesome to either have to go to Baton Rouge or have the Tigers come to Pasadena.  Better yet, this would be an awesome BCS bowl game.  At least we met on the hardwood this last March (fortunately we won!).
  2.  Minnesota vs. Washington - For some reason, this seems like a natural.  Perhaps because of their northerly locations; or perhaps both programs have been mediocre on the gridiron though the Huskies have the edge on the hardwood.

by Minnesota Bruinfan on Dec 23, 2006 9:47 AM PST   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Bruins Nation, an unofficial daily online scrap book covering the greatest collegiate athletic program in the nation. GO BRUINS.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

080513__0038_1_small
A Message to the SPTR's: It's About Judgment Not Rules
13-9_ucla_baby____036_small
Videos from the Rose Bowl's Field of Dreams
10113_big_small
The Impact of Labor Day Football On National TV
13-9_small
Magical Mystery Tour
9ceb0165-b773-443d-8a5f-cb4befbe4c28_small
A Tennessee Gameplan (through NCAA Football 09)

Recent FanPosts

9ceb0165-b773-443d-8a5f-cb4befbe4c28_small
UCLA #4 on Top 10 "Gutsiest" BCS Teams
Telemachus_small
Coach Neuheisel "In My Own Words"
Bruinsnation_small
Howland Digging JK's Offseason Workout Results
Telemachus_small
FIDO
Small
Pac 10 v SEC: Some more facts
Getcarter_small
"This is why they fired you Karl Dorrell"
Bruinsnation_small
Hire Lavin & Toledo = Get Inducted Into UCLA Hall Of Fame?
Telemachus_small
Still basking in the glow

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

094_small Ajax

Bruinsnation_small Nestor

Menelaus2_small Menelaus

Arron_afflalo1_small Tydides

Brad_pitt_as_achilles_small Achilles

Small Meriones

Telemachus_small Telemachus

Small Odysseus

ad

Site Meter