Bruins Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:



Around SBN: On the Road to Madison Bar-right-arrows



Does Everyone Really Do It?

NCAA violations.  Criminal behavior.  Off the field scandals.  No real problem.  They're just kids.  And everybody does it.

It's a common catchphrase.  More often heard from supporters of programs who've recently found their collective hands caught in the cookie jar. With USC struggling to endure two very bad weeks off the field, Trojan sycophants have trotted out this tired refrain again and again. And some so-called impartial college football commentators in the blogosphere would like us to believe that the incidents of criminality and wrongdoing we've seen in the recent past (included the alleged incidents affecting USC) happen at all major programs. They do so, perhaps, in the hopes of deflecting attention, and culpability, from their embattled program.

This sentiment is reflected in a recent article on CFR as follows:

Here's a hint: every program is guilty of something, and most are unabashed repeat offenders.

In fairness, CFR just starts with this premise before raising another issue, speculating that a Gentlemen's Agreement exists between coaches that keeps some scandalous, rule breaking behavior away from the light of day. Does such an agreement exist? I don't know. It may well.

But, is the premise accurate? Does every program really do it? And does every program share equally in the blame?

I don't think so.

Before you think me naive, of course, many programs, coaches and players occasionally do the wrong thing. And it's naive indeed to believe that no programs ever get their hands dirty, or, worse, to blindly profess that your own team is immune from such behavior. Even at schools with the best of intentions, the highest standards, and the most rigorous discipline, bad things will happen from time to time.

But, experience and commonsense tells us that bad things happen at some schools more than others. And some programs have been downright notorious for their systematic and repeated misconduct. The infamous Miami program under Erickson, and others, come to mind. And it's not just a conspiracy between coaches, reporters and the NCAA that makes it appear as though some schools are more blameworthy than others. It's because some schools are more blameworthy than others. Whether it's knowing involvement in NCAA violations or simply fostering a chaotic environment devoid of genuine discipline, some schools push (and push through) the boundaries more than others. And some teams, the ones that weed out troublemakers early, enforce their rules consistently, and demand that players stay away from situations which could lead to trouble, those teams have less problems.

And, as a result, there is no moral equivalence between programs. Repeated patterns of misconduct cannot and should not be excused as just another day at the office. They should be recognized for what they are: sometimes a random event attributable to the devices of young men, but sometimes the foreseeable product of a program that doesn't take the steps necessary to keep its ship from sailing off course. Sometimes it's just what you'd expect from a "players' coach" and an environment where players who assault people are allowed to suit up for the next game.

This isn't just about bashing USC, though I believe they richly deserve the national attention they have earned through an impressive pattern of misconduct since Pete Carroll took the reigns. It's also about demanding that our own program keep its house in order.

But, any way you look at it, some schools do it more than others. And, for that, they deserve our attention and scorn.

I think we know this. And, just like the parent whose precocious child tries to explain away his or her drug use, or other malfeasance, by saying: "But, Mom, all the kids do it", we know better. They all don't do it, at least not all the same. And those who think otherwise are deluding themselves.

0 recs | Comment 3 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

Experience and common sense
There are so many good points in this gem that I am not sure where to began.

I think the key phrase you bring up here is "systematic and repeated misconduct." This is happening at certain insitutions. This is not happening everywhere in college football. This is exactly what took Erickson's Miami program down, and this may spell trouble for Carroll at USC.

Another aspect I think is also important is how we deal with these situations ourselves.

That is why I crticized Dorrell for not suspending Ward and Hale from the team (on an interim basis) after he learned that there were warrants issued for  their arrest.

Our program needs to exercise complete control to make sure we project unquestionable image of integrity and accountabilty at UCLA.

PB over at BON also has a very interesting post on this issue making a good point:

Anyway, cynics will decry the political aspect of all this, but that's the reality we're facing here, and it's not going to change. College football is big, big business. And with so much at stake, there's simply no other option but hyper-control of every aspect of the business. And the important lesson here for USC, and every elite program, should be obvious. No, you can't avoid recruiting some guys who are going to screw up - sometimes badly. That's an unreasonable standard that very few demand. These are, after all, 18-22 year old males.

It's how you deal with situations as they arise that defines you. Do you foster a culture of accountability, or are you willy nilly about enforcement of rules? Do you brush everything under the rug in irrational hubris, or do you do your best to not only win championships, but develop solid young men? And for heaven's sake, even if that last standard seems unattainable, do you at least work your tail off to -appear- to be taking these things seriously? In USC's case, the answer has been `no.' But at Texas, they run a much tighter business.

Again to reiterate what you wrote M, there is no moral equivalence between Carroll's law less football program and the one at UCLA. No matter how much certain Trojan alums pipe up in certain so called impartial college blogs and try to make believe this happens everywhere, it simpley doesn't.

Great post M.  Great post.

by Nestor on May 15, 2006 2:45 PM PDT   0 recs

Integrity and accountability
Those are all great observations.  

And you are very right to emphasis how we treat these situations ourselves. Every time something like what happened with Medlock and Ward/Hall comes up, UCLA has an opportunity to show its players/fans/rivals that we are going to compete with integrity. And, when we do the right thing, that is something to be proud of.

by Menelaus on May 15, 2006 3:02 PM PDT to parent up   0 recs

We just hope that
KD did some reasonable diligence and deemed that the current situation with Ward and Hale do not merit any kind of suspension, otherwise WTF is he waiting for.

by Mikeohwen on May 15, 2006 7:14 PM PDT   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Bruins Nation, an unofficial daily online scrap book covering the greatest collegiate athletic program in the nation. GO BRUINS.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

Telemachus_small
Photos: WSU @ UCLA
13-9_ucla_baby____036_small
Check Your Mail...
080513__0038_1_small
Relentless Optimism and the Creation of a Winning Culture
Telemachus_small
Photos: Fresno State @ UCLA

Recent FanPosts

Pompomsucks_small
"Several Pac-10 schools" file complaint about Peetie's cheating
Bruinsnation_small
B Diddy Gives Ben Ball Warriors Another Shout Out
10113_big_small
Non-Revenue Sports Bruin Review and Calendar
Getcarter_small
Coach Howland > Ratface
Bruinsnation_small
The Wacky UCLA Marketing Dept At It Again
Small
O.J.'s Final Message
California_flag_sun_small
Dec. 5, 2008 - O.J. Gets His Due
Small
The New Version of the Las Vegas Bowl
Small
Free pair tix for Wazzu behind Bruin Bench

Post_icon New FanPost All FanPosts Carrot-mini


Managers

094_small Ajax

Bruinsnation_small Nestor

Menelaus2_small Menelaus

Arron_afflalo1_small Tydides

Brad_pitt_as_achilles_small Achilles

Small Meriones

Telemachus_small Telemachus

Small Odysseus

ad

Site Meter