Richard Brehaut Playing Baseball This Summer: What Does It Mean?
This bit of news came out last week and rich87 got to it quickly, but we've got a little more on Richard Brehaut's decision to play baseball this summer. For those who missed it, Brehaut joined the baseball team before the 2011 season, although only on a part-time basis. He was a very good baseball player in high school, but hadn't played since his junior season and decided to give the sport a try again. He was out at practice and games, although he did not play, but when spring practice rolled around, he wasn't around the diamond so much and was with the football team.
When he initially decided to play baseball in addition to football he got Rick Neuheisel's blessing and made it clear that football came first. When football and baseball conflicted, he would pick football and he would make sure to get all his throwing work in with his receivers even with his baseball work. It seemed like baseball was just this thing he wanted to get a feel for again.
That all changed when Brehaut decided that he would play baseball this summer too. It's one thing to play baseball for UCLA during the season, but to go as far as putting in the summer work? Well at that point it becomes serious. He's putting in the work of every other baseball player.
The question was raised, is Brehaut committed to football? He's at UCLA on a football scholarship and he's not some guy way down on the depth chart. He's competing for the starting quarterback job. He had an uneven season last year and needs to get all his work in. A guy who is going to compete for a starting quarterback job in the Pac-10 can't have his focus split, can he? Brehaut is making a big mistake and neglecting his football responsibilities, right?
It's not that cut and dry. There is more to it than one or the other so let's take a deeper look at this.
First of all, Brehaut isn't hopping over to baseball because he's got the starting catcher job wrapped up or anything of the sort. He hasn't played a collegiate game yet and his games in the California League will be his first games since junior year of high school.
Steve Rodriguez did sign with the Diamondbacks so the starting catcher job is open, but Brehaut will have to pass up Tyler Heineman, who will be a junior, played in 23 games last year, hit a respectable .261 and is considered a plus defensive catcher. Toss in the possibility of Austin Hedges passing on the pros and he might also have to pass up the top rated catcher recruit in the country. Point is, Brehaut is not going with baseball because it is the easy choice.
Another point in this is that Brehaut is playing locally. He's playing with a team that plays its home games in Compton so he is around. He is attending summer school and is getting up at 6 am to get his throwing in with his receivers. When fall camp starts up, he'll be there for that too. Brehaut is taking the step of playing summer ball and getting games in, but he's also making sure to get all his football work in and he's in summer school. That's pretty impressive.
Quarterbacks also playing baseball isn't so rare either. In the Pac-10 recently Dennis Dixon and Joe Borchard did it. Kyle Parker recently did it for Clemson and many others have done it, including people like John Elway. That's not to say that Brehaut is any of those guys, but quarterbacks playing baseball has been done successfully on both fronts.
Even with all of this, it is reasonable to question Brehaut's commitment to football. Sure, he's getting his football work in, but that time he's spending playing baseball he could be spending getting even more football work in. This guy has a chance to be the starting quarterback of a Pac-12 football team.
Some have speculated that he feels as if Kevin Prince is Neuheisel's guy so he's look elsewhere. It's possible that he feels a little lost without Norm Chow, the guy who was instrumental in bringing him to Westwood. All of that is speculation and nothing more, but it's also just as possible that he's missed playing baseball and wants to get back to playing it.
Whatever his reasons, Brehaut is playing baseball this summer. He's getting his football work in, but then he's grabbing his catcher's gear and bat and heading to the diamond. How this affects his ability to win the starting quarterback job and perform at the Rose Bowl this fall, well, that's a complete question mark.
45 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
RB's decision to play BB...
First off…Playing QB now (I think) is a whole lot more demanding than in the 80’s. RB after 3 years still doesn’t come across as if he “gets it” yet when it comes to executing his posotion. I think RN said he still makes poor decisions. So there is the “Mental” aspect he could be refineing instead of playing bb.
Even more basic is his ability to play the position. His accuracy isn’t the best. How is his arm strength,touch and finding the open reciever?Would spending more time regarding these issues suffer playing bb? Or if not, how does this improve his deficiences? I don’t see how playing bb helps RB playing FB.
New coordinater Johnson has introduced new things…how is RB’s grasp of changes?
So good question Ryan, what are we to make of this? It’s not like his mastered the position and is just filling out some summer time space. To me he is making a statement…
by GogetemBruins on Jun 21, 2011 3:37 PM PDT up reply actions
2 words, 5 syllables
Jackie Robinson
by peggysue69 on Jun 21, 2011 1:25 PM PDT via mobile reply actions
Exactly what I was thinking.
Great minds, and all that.
There are plenty of others, of course, but those five syllables are all that need be uttered.
I could have sworn Matt Ware and Ricky Manning Jr
also played Summer Ball.
As long as he can balance it, good for him. Although it’s interesting that he’s a catcher, I’d hate to think he’s possibly hurting his knees in the squat. They can’t crash into the catcher in summer leagues, right? horrible flashbacks to Buster Posey
Also, Brehaut has got to consider that baseball has the potential for a much longer career than football. Remember Jeff Samardzjia’s choice to pass up the NFL for baseball.
I stuck with quarterbacks
if we want to include all football players playing baseball then the list gets really long.
Two roads diverged in a wood and I – I tweeted my followers to ask which I should take
by Ryan Rosenblatt on Jun 21, 2011 1:47 PM PDT up reply actions
I will split answer your question
1) No, I don’t have a problem with Bre playing baseball
but
2) I do think it shows he is more interested in playing baseball than football.
the coaching staff should act accordingly.
by silverlakebruin on Jun 21, 2011 1:45 PM PDT reply actions
I agree with #1, but not #2
1 – I don’t know if we can “have a problem” with RB’s legal activities during his spare time. He’s a grown ass man, and as long as he honors the terms of his scholarship, I’m not sure how anyone can “have a problem” with his choice.
2 – I disagree that it shows that he is more interested in baseball than football. I think it shows that he is not as interested in football as we would like him to be. It might be saying more about us than him.
He is honoring the terms of his scholarships and pursuing other interests that he enjoys. He is not missing any organized football time, but he is not spending every waking minute honing his craft either. This discussion is sort of akin to the missed “voluntary” workouts in the NFL. Of course, players do not have to attend those workouts, just as RB doesn’t have to neglect his other interests in order to work on his game, but somehow the conversation has switched to the point where the player is doing something wrong if he fails to attend.
That said, RB may not be willing to put in the extra work, but somebody else will be. I wouldn’t be surprised if KP and BH both look better than RB in fall camp.
by AllHailMightyBruins on Jun 21, 2011 3:55 PM PDT up reply actions
This is pretty much where I am
The criticisms I have seen hurled toward CRN based on this have been totally unfair and offbase (note I am not talking about silverlake).
Let's not judge too quickly
He has played football for 3 years at UCLA, counting the redshirt year. He has not played baseball until this year. How does that show more interest in baseball than football? Just asking! I think he is the type of person that can handle both, as others before him have done.
by Forever a Bruin on Jun 21, 2011 2:58 PM PDT reply actions
he didn't redshirt.
he’s going to be a true junior next year.
Also, how in the hell are we comparing a shaky backup trying to be a starter qb to Jackie Robinson and John Elway, or Ricky Manning Jr. & Matt Ware for that matter. Those guys were all GREAT in college! Have any of their butts ever seen a bench in college or held a clip board? This spring and summer was Bre’s big chance to make up ground and pass Prince for the starting QB job, and instead, he chooses to play baseball part time?! Really Richard?! You need all of the work that you can get, and this is what you do. Wow. This reminds me of when I was a teenager doing yardwork in the backyard. I think I was working for about 3 hours, when I finally decided to put down the rake. I told my dad I was tired and was going to go out with my friends. He said, “If you have the energy to go out with your friends, then you have the energy to finish this yardwork.” Needless to say, I didn’t go anywhere that night. Pick up the rake Richard.
formerly Westwood78
by PhoenixBruin on Jun 21, 2011 3:51 PM PDT up reply actions 1 recs
Dennis Dixon.
After a mediocre ’06 season, and with his confidence shaky at best, DD played baseball the following summer. And ended up leading the Ducks to a #2 ranking and a clear path to the BCS title game…and the story ends right there.
Ducks GOOOOD. Fuskies BAAAAAD.
by BigGreenWreckingMachine on Jun 21, 2011 4:05 PM PDT reply actions
Wasn't on my list of names that he shouldn't be compared to...
…so you think that this summer league season could lead us to the BCS. Why didn’t we try that before?!!!
formerly Westwood78
by PhoenixBruin on Jun 21, 2011 4:27 PM PDT up reply actions
How does your comment help with anything?
We get it. You are not happy w Brehaut’s decision. You made that point above. All BigGreen was doing was providing some context. He didn’t suggest it means UCLA will also waltz into BCS. Instead you snark it up with a comment that does nothing but only adds to toxicity around the program.
Relax. Take a chill pill. Let the season play out. Let’s see what happens this Fall camp. If you have something thoughtful to share, please do. If you want to just throw up snark adding nothing to the discussion here, find a message board.
I understand what he is saying.
What I am saying is that we are not that team that Dixon took over. We need a leader, and instead of being that leader, he decided to do something else besides what he was brought in to do. I expect more from him, that’s all.
formerly Westwood78
by PhoenixBruin on Jun 21, 2011 5:45 PM PDT up reply actions
people being way too generous, IMHO.
most of last year, there was debate about Prince and Brehaut, with numerous comments here and elsewhere to the effect that Chow favored Prince unduly and was hypercritical of Brehaut, while Neuheisel was more willing to try to get Brehaut on the field.
Chow – in his ever diplomatic way – would make comments about Brehaut not knowing the playbook and not going through his progressions; sparking angry rebuttals from Brehaut fans. IMHO, Brehaut playing baseball is totally in keeping with a guy with insufficient commitment to football to be a top-class Pac-12 performer. It doesn’t PROVE that he isn’t committed, but it fits in with a preexisting pattern, asserted by coaches, that he doesn’t have his head in the game.
With Chow gone and a new offensive coordinator – and a change in the QB coaching situation – the opportunity is there for Brehaut to overcome any alleged favoritism and make his case for the starting job. He is going up against an oft-injured Prince and a true freshman Hundley. If the chance to impress new coaches and the window of opportunity presented by the lack of a real incumbent QB does not motivate him, this seems like a major strike against him.
People looking at “QBs playing baseball” outside of the context of the current UCLA QB and coaching situation seem to me to be missing the point.
let me clarify the last line
hearing about QBs who have handled both provides some information that may be new to people and provide additional historical background; but focusing too much on those comparisons to defend Brehaut’s decision is to ignore the importance of the very specific context. Given the situation, and the energy people usually have around the QB position, I am surprised how mellow people are on this thread – but then, it is the first day of summer :-)
Has anyone consdidered that Brehaut might be playing baseball for fun?
College kid having fun during the summer.
Is he allowed to do that?
sure
he’s allowed to make any choice he wants. Just as the coaches will be allowed to put him at the end of the bench and put a touted but inexperienced freshman into the starting lineup. And fans will be allowed to be annoyed that he isn’t putting his best effort into providing UCLA with the best performance in exchange for the scholarship he has been awarded.
At the same time
We are not going to allow repetitive potshots at our student athletes. Folks are welcome to vent that kind of “annoyance” on message boards.
by Nestor on Jun 21, 2011 5:53 PM PDT via mobile up reply actions
confused
got issued a “don’t lecture the moderators” warning for a comment in reference to Gen2Bruin1987’s sarcasm…? Totally agree with Nestor that we really need to wait and see re: Brehaut’s performance, disagree with Gen2Bruin1987’s passive aggressive sarcasm.
by VeniceBruin on Jun 23, 2011 10:37 AM PDT up reply actions
I have no issue with it
He’s doing his throwing work, he’s not missing camp, he’s watching tape, he’s going to summer school. If he weren’t playing baseball then he’d be spending that time playing video games or something like that. If he were skipping out on football work to do this stuff then I’d raise an eyebrow, but I’ve haven’t seen or heard anything to indicate that he’s doing any less football work than he would have done otherwise.
Two roads diverged in a wood and I – I tweeted my followers to ask which I should take
by Ryan Rosenblatt on Jun 21, 2011 6:09 PM PDT reply actions
He tweeted this mins ago:
About to head out to throwing with my Bruins. We’re workin out here! #Pac12Champs
So for folks who want to post repetitive takes against this kid, I would recommend to chill out. And we are not going to tolerate repetitive shots against our student athletes.
At least it is being active, not playing the xbox and smoking some ... like some of his peers.
I just hope he brings it hard and gives a good shot at getting the starting position.
I'm completely fine with it
so long as he manages his time wisely between both sports. Since it seems like he’s talked this thing out between both CRN and CJS and he has an understanding of which comes first, etc., I say have at it and best of luck, Richard.
"The true athlete should have character, not be a character."- John Wooden
"Always turn a negative situation into a positive situation."- Michael Jordan
twitter:@firstto100
i dont he has is heart in football
he is a party boy … i have a niece at UCLA right now who lived on his dorm floor last year …. he pledged SAE…. on her Facebook page.. plenty of pics of him partying it up … i mean after all he is a college student but at the same time the football program is paying for your education… i know he has changed his name on Facebook .. he is not Richard Brehaut … so in my opinion … if you are football player .. especially a quarterback.. you need to devote your time to the program … it doesnt mean not living the student life … but it means prioritizing … and this kid it seems like partying, girls and baseball are taking over for football
I believe Aikman also pledged SAE
Neu partied it up. As did Cade. When I look to hire kids from UCLA I look for kids who are well balanced and have healthy outlook on life. Brehaut is living a dream while taking advantage of all opportunities afforded to him. Shoot KL, JF, JS, RW, LMR … these guys were not wallflowers at ucla. If you think they were just having milk and cookies besides playing ben ball and going to classes, then you are being incredibly naive. So stop it w the ridiculous attacks and comments.
by Nestor on Jun 22, 2011 5:27 AM PDT via mobile up reply actions 2 recs
Cade
Mr. McNown was … uh… legendary for his partying it up… I heard ridic stories about him at the Playboy Mansion. Believe he got a lifetime ban for hooking up with one of Hef’s girls.
I heard he was a decent QB.
In your own words, "take a chill pill."
While I acknowledge that UCLADave did opine on RB’s character, many other folks who you attack for “shots” aren’t making personal attacks against RB. They’re merely acknowledging the existence of “facts” which tend to suggest certain things. To the best of my knowledge, no one simply acknowledging these things has once said that in the event they are true, that RB is a bad person, or a poor student-athlete, or anything near to personal like that. They are merely offering that IF certain facts are true, then they may SUGGEST certain other facts regarding the likelihood of his ability to perform in the future that may or may not turn out to be true. This to me seems like the very essence of furthering a discussion – we are, after all, clearly creating and analyzing hypothetical situations, not being privy to everything UCLA football related. And it may just be me, but I don’t think that public performance is a personal matter.
Maybe.......
the knocks against RB’s QBing were the result of Chow’s system and not RB’s ability? I don’t think the second coming of Cade or Troy would have thrived in Chow’s offense scheme.
I’m interested to see what our QB’s do in our new offensive scheme. If they suck then we know it’s talent. If they thrive then we know who to blame for our 4-8 season. I think we sure as hell have the talent now it’s up to the coaches to put it together!
color me puzzled
This kind of reminds me of Drew Henson. Henson sat on the bench his first two years at Michigan behind Tom Brady before finally earning the starting job in 2000 after Brady graduated. The main difference, however, is Henson was the Gatorade High School Baseball Player of the Year and was drafted in the third round by the Yankees. Henson spent summers playing minor league baseball in the Yankee organization then played football with the Wolverines in the fall until pursuing baseball full-time after his junior season.
What baffles me is that I don’t recall Brehaut being a touted baseball prospect in high school. If, like Ryan says, he’s a catcher, then his chances of earning the starting catcher job are even more remote than him supplanting Prince as the starting quarterback. He hasn’t played baseball since his junior year of high school, and hitting a baseball isn’t like riding bike.
Personally, I’m all for the kid, any kid, pursuing their heart’s content so long as it does not interfere with his obligations. I do have to question the rationale this late into this athletic career. Brehaut is at the proverbial crossroads of his career. He has two (three if he redshirts) years left of football eligibility. He has a two-year starter in front of him and a highly-touted freshman behind him. If he wants to play baseball, he has to deal with players who have not taken the kind of prolonged break from the game he has. Unless he’s Robert Redford, there’s no chance of him having a professional baseball career.
I really hope he knows what he’s doing because I don’t want to see him languish in both sports.
Not a Problem at all
Since the summer league in question is based in SoCal it is a total non-issue!
Let's all pull for Brehaut
He needs our support, as do all our BRUINS. Baseball shouldn’t hurt him. Let’s cut him some slack!
by Forever a Bruin on Jun 23, 2011 10:02 AM PDT reply actions
Good for Him
Went out Compton last Sunday night. Unfortunately, he wasn’t playing.
He’s not shucking his responsibilities. I’d like to see what he can do on the diamond next year.

by 


















