Bruins Nation: An SB Nation Community

Navigation: Jump to content areas:


Sports blogs for fans, by fans.
Around SBN: Cal RB Jahvid Best Seriously Injured, Carted Off Field

December 5, 1998: "Our Bill Buckner" Moment(s)

Warning: this post is going to cut open some old but raw wounds, recalling my most painful day as a fanatic of UCLA football. If you don't want to deal with the agony, stop right here. -N GO BRUINS.

December 5, 1998, a day unquestionably is my most painful one as a UCLA Bruin. I imagine everyone here in some way or another remember this:



There are just so many ifs.

Most of you probably remember the non-fumble by Brad Melsby which became the last turning point of the entire game. He was obviously down.

What if the refs. made the right call on that play?

But I think more crucial that what-if was the one involving ?Poli Butter Fingers? Dixon fumbling away earlier in the 4th quarter. Don?t remember what I am referring to?

The play that is burned into my brain is the one that shows up at 3:31 minute mark in the video I posted above.

What if Brian Poli "Butterfingers" Dixon didn't fumble that ball? IMHO that was our Bill Buckner moment.

I still believe if Dixon hadn?t fumbled that ball away, we would have marched on to score another TD, and put Miami away for good in that game. We would have gone on to beat Tennessee in the Fiesta Bowl and never looked back.

Our program would have been at a different level. And we wouldn't be saddled with a mentality where we are told to sit down and shut up and be happy with a program that is not confident in itself about contending for a conference championship, let alone a national championship.

Anyways, here on BN I have visited the other end of the memory lane of Bruin moments by posting Tyus's magical 4.8 seconds and ask you guys to recount exactly where you were and what you were doing when that moment happened. Might as well go the other route. Where were you on December 5, 1998?

I was shell shocked, staring at the big screen blankly at Champions Sports Bar, in downtown Boston. I was with four other friends - UCLA alums who were attending law schools around Boston - who sat with me motionless having no clue what to say after that Melsby fumble. Pretty much all of them on the verge of tears. And there was nothing we could say to make each other feel better. We knew we had just choked away probably the best opportunity to appear in a national championship game and permanently alter the perception around UCLA football program in last 20-30 years.

What was even more heartbreaking about that game was that it was televised on Eastern Sports Programming Network infront of the blowhard Game Day crew. Through the whole game the insufferable Lee Corso was running his mouth about the soft UCLA football team who?d rather be on their surf boards than play football. And that one single game crystallized the national perception around football program.

Toledo never recovered from that game as the program went down the toilet. And when we had a golden opportunity to take the program in a new direction four years ago, the old Donahue hack ? Bob Field ? made sure UCLA stuck in the same mindset from the mediocre years of Donahue which was limited to the vision of winning conference championships and beating Southern Cal.

And Dorrell to date has failed to live up to even those expectations extolled by Donahue.

What would have happened if Poli Dixon handn?t fumbled or refs called Melsby down?

I?d bet this particular Nation is still agonizing over those plays just like the Red Sox one did over Bill Buckner, until they shook off the proverbial monkey off their back in 2004.

Unless Karl Dorell wins a Pac-10 championship, beats Southern Cal, and gets UCLA to at least a Rose Bowl, those questions will not go away any time soon.

That is why it is imperative for him to either get it done or hit the road this coming season.

GO BRUINS.

0 recs  |  Comment 27 comments

Story-email Email Printer Print

Comments

Display:

My bad guys
for some reason I had the comments disabled in this post. Fire away if you have any thoughts ...

by Nestor on Jul 5, 2007 6:56 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Horrible
I was watching at my fiance's apartment in Hermosa Beach. I was devastated. I remember walking along the strand in absolute shell shock. I was cursing the refs, cursing our defense, cursing Poli-Dixon, even cursing that damn hurricane that moved the game after the SUC game (what if we had played them earlier in the year?).

That win catapulted Miami's program, and set ours back to mediocrity. I will never forget it.

I haven't forgotten how much our defense really sucked that year. Don't know how we would've fared against UT, likely would've been underdogs, but who knows? That was also the inaugural BCS year. I am more upset at what it did to our program afterwards. I will never forget.

by godblesstyus95 on Jul 5, 2007 7:49 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Where in Hermosa Beach?
I'm in Hermosa Beach with my fiancee as well.

by BruinFan1 on Jul 6, 2007 12:18 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Monterey Blvd
Just North of Pier Avenue.

Moved to San Diego in 2000.

Truly miss Hermosa...great bars, restaurants, etc..

by godblesstyus95 on Jul 6, 2007 4:05 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Yep
I pretty much live on Pier Ave. It's a wonderful place.

by BruinFan1 on Jul 8, 2007 12:29 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Ouch.
I'll say it again. Ouch. And then there was the Rose Bowl against Wisconsin... Ouch. Damnit. Wasn't one of our key defensive players missing when we played the 'Canes?
Duke and North Carolina called: They want Steve Lavin back. GO BRUINS!!

by Allofmybros on Jul 5, 2007 9:10 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

What if...
...our defense had been able to tackle Edgerrin James within a few yards of the line of scrimmage?  I was with some fellow Bruins at a house party watching this game.  Honestly, while I was very bummed about the loss, I never bothered to "what if" the missed plays on offense b/c with the way our defense played that game, it was hard to feel like we were the best team in the nation.  

I do feel that Edge should be making donations to UCLA to thank us for the millions of dollars in his signing bonus that we gave him that game.

On a side note, I'd saved a lil' over a grand in preparation for making the trip out to Tempe for the Fiesta Bowl.  I ended up going to Vegas instead and blew that within a couple hours in what ended up being a brutal trip.

by insomniacslounge on Jul 5, 2007 11:04 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

never recovered
that is the truth.  Can you imagine what it would have been like to play in the first ever BCS championship game?!  I knew when that game was rescheduled that we wouldn't be the same team.  Toledo did suspend a defensive player which caused a huge problem in the locker room.  There were rumors that the defense checked out of the game because of it.  It sure looked like they did.

Horrible game for our program, great game for Miami.

by DumpDorrell on Jul 5, 2007 11:16 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

There were also rumors
about defensive players wearing black arm bands to protest policy against affirmative action. A complete breakdown at all levels.

by Nestor on Jul 6, 2007 4:38 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

yes I remember that
there was one player in particular whose name I cant remember who went public to one of the local papers about it. That caused friction in the locker room as well. That same player went on to play in the NFL and was in the Super Bowl last year or two years ago making the same big stink as he did back then. Guess what happened.  He lost in the Super Bowl as well.

by DumpDorrell on Jul 7, 2007 12:54 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

The worst
It was Bill Buckner, Leon Durham ('84 Cubs playoffs), and Donnie Moore ('86 vs. Dave Henderson) all rolled into one.  I was decorating the Christmas tree, playing holiday tunes, and trying to be festive, but for some reason I had an uneasy feeling all through the game.  I remember yelling, "NOOOO!" when P-D fumbled that ball away, and then thinking that we just blew the season.  

I don't know that we would have beaten Peyton Manning and Tennessee with our defense, but that would have been easier to stomach than losing to Miami...a program that became known for thuggery, cheating, multiple arrests, academic fraud, and a coaching staff that pretended to know nothing while openly thumbing their noses at the NCAA, practically daring anyone to question their integrity, enjoying both the adoration and protection of the local media which never so much as...as... wait, which football program was I talking about again?

by Class of 86 on Jul 5, 2007 11:46 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Agree
One thing though Peyton Manning had already graduated. I believe Tenn. won that championship with Tee Martin at QB.

by Nestor on Jul 6, 2007 4:37 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

whoops
You're right, my bad on PM, he was gone by then.. Sorry, I live in San Diego and we Charger fans have erased all memories of the '98 draft, if you know what I mean.

by Class of 86 on Jul 6, 2007 8:34 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

What?
You mean Ryan Leaf didn't work out?

by Barnes2JJ on Jul 6, 2007 8:38 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

No, he worked out great
We won 4 straight Super Bowls with Ryan Leaf and he's headed to Canton.  I was of course referring to Clifford Ivory, our 6th round pick out of Troy State who, sadly, was released during training camp.

by Class of 86 on Jul 6, 2007 9:37 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Ha!
Memo to Chargers:  Don't give any more $10 million signing bonuses to lunatics.

by Barnes2JJ on Jul 6, 2007 9:41 AM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

The Miami game was our family vacation that year.
My sister had graduated from UCLA.  My brother had recently played football at and graduated from UCLA.  And I was going to Anderson.  Also, my parents had just named our new puppy Bruin-Belle.  So why not make that game a family vacation?

We were sitting in the row just in front of the 'Canes student section.  They were obnoxious.  So when we were up by 17 mid-4th quarter I was turning around and talking more smack than ever.  And when the 'Canes scored their last TD, we couldn't get out of that stadium fast enough.  Needless to say, the last 24 hours of that vacation were spent being pissed off.

by bornagainbruin on Jul 6, 2007 7:35 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Sickening
That game is filled with "what ifs."  I remember watching it at home and just feeling sick.  

This was the "agony of defeat" for us.

by Barnes2JJ on Jul 6, 2007 8:11 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

I could see it coming
When they postponed the game, I could see the handwriting on the wall. I am unable to view the rerun here as it is too painful. As the season wore on, and the defense looked more and more suspect, we could see fate coming at us like a freight train. I suppose there was no way to go ahead and have the game in another location early in the season. I believe our esteemed Peter Dalis had a hand in that one.
Bill
BillSouthBay

by Mensgym on Jul 6, 2007 9:12 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

don't really recall
where I was at the time. But for me, it really didn't hit me as hard as it obviously did others, mostly because I had expected to lose at some point and so I was not devastated. Ever since I started at UCLA, we have ALWAYS found a way to lose. We had two great shots when Aikman was QB-and we lost. With the '98 team, we had the best UCLA offense I had ever seen, and maybe ever will see, but our D was awful all season. The run D in particular was amazingly bad, and what made it worse was that there was some solid talent on the defensive side of the ball. According to the clip Nestor embedded, UCLA gave up on average 25 ppg, and so half the teams we played that year scored more than 25. IIRC Oregon scored 38, Oregon State 31 and there were few games where our defense made plays. Instead, '98 was a season where we just outscored everyone, and it caught up with us against Miami and then again against Ron Dayne and Wisconsin.

It sucked, but I really didn't have a meltdown because Flabby Bob had some great recruiting classes coming in and with his offensive schemes I thought we could really win the national title if he could just get another Rocky Long or some other solid D coordinator.

by ucladj89 on Jul 6, 2007 9:44 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Where I was...
I was at my mom's house watching on TV, Yelling about the knee being down.  I knew the Poli-Dixon Fumble was his fault and cost us as much as any bad call, but I was sooo pissed.

Also we would have beaten Tennesee because we had a pretty good secondary; the problem was the secondary had to stop Edjerin James, and later Ron Dayne.

And the other big reason we can point to wrt the team playing flat on Defense is that the AD cheaped out and didn't want to pay for an extra day in Miami so the players didn't have time to get acclimated to the Miami weather.

by isodore on Jul 6, 2007 10:05 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Interesting thing about that video
On the part where UCLA supposedly fumbles to give Miami their last possesion, rather than showing the Melsby phantom fumble, it shows the Poli-Dixon one from earlier.

They know it themselves. If instant replay was around back then we win this game. I believe that after a close call like that UCLA mans up and beats Tenn.

Remember how we almost lost the Stanford game and then came out hot against 'SC? I believe a similiar scenario would have played out.

But we got screwed and the team collapsed and had no motivation for the Rose Bowl. It didn't help that UCLA fans sold their tickets to Badgers.

I remember when my Dad cancelled our Tempe trip after the game. That was a horrible day.

There are plenty of factors for why that game went that way, but none of them would have mattered if not for that crucial call.

by True Blue and Gold on Jul 6, 2007 2:31 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

What a lousy day
I was watching the game at a bar up in Chico.  Got so pissed when the Hurrigangstaz scored their last TD I threw a plastic chair across the bar and was kicked out (imagine that).  Adding insult to injury: the Miami QB was from Dana Hills HS.  What a terrible day.  

I live in Chapel Hill, North Carolina now and I'm just waiting to greet Butch Davis to the Tar Heels with a good swift kick in the nuts.

Go Bruins

by Bruins gave me an Ulcer on Jul 6, 2007 6:39 PM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Where I was
I was at home with a friend watching the game, To this day I am convinced Melsby did NOT fumble that football I said that when I saw the play happen and I say it again today his knee's hit the ground

Man I was pissed after that game, Cade had a great day but the Rose Bowl and Miami game god our defense just stunk

by Bruin10 on Jul 7, 2007 4:14 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

I was in bed...
It was a pretty early game if I recall correctly. I was in bed enjoying it, waiting for my soccer game to start...I played like crap in that game but we still won. I was supposed to go out that night with some friends and they couldn't figure out why I was so down and had no desire to hit the town...well, they were from Europe, didn't quite get the college football thing...AAARRRGHHH!!! I HATE MIAMI!!!

by tasser10 on Jul 7, 2007 11:16 AM PDT reply actions   0 recs

Missed the game
and a lot of ulcers.  I was at a rehearsal, and got the final score in the car on the way home.  Didn't bother to listen further.

I thought it might happen once the game got rescheduled from a time when we could have beaten anyone to a time when I didn't think we had much of a chance.  

by Fox 71 on Jul 7, 2007 1:38 PM PDT up reply actions   0 recs

Comments For This Post Are Closed


User Tools

Welcome to Bruins Nation, an unofficial daily online scrap book covering the greatest collegiate athletic program in the nation. GO BRUINS.
Start posting about the Bruins »

Join SB Nation and dive into communities focused on all your favorite teams.

FanPosts

Community blog posts and discussion.

Recommended FanPosts

2145443360_ab27e15b11_b_small
Bleeding Blue and Gold ... Always
Morrell_small
The UCLA Passing Game Under Norm Chow
Arron_afflalo1_small
NBA Opening Night (Bruin Edition)
Rowing_picture_small
Football is like a box of chocolates
Th_ucla182c2_small
Broke the $3000 mark today- Thank you, Bruins!

Recent FanPosts

Bruinsnation_small
Harrison Barnes' Amazing Trip To Howlandwood
Bruinsnation_small
The Big Red Signs Off
Moreyouknow_small
Pre-Game Guesses: Oregon State Results
Screen_shot_2009-09-28_at_6
13-9’s Tidbits: Washington Edition
Small
Hartman doesnt get it
Ucla_small
Ben Ball 09-10, Day 1
Small
Google News Bruin feed created
Bruinsnation_small
Adam Maya/OC Register In CYA Mode: Fails To Take Responsibility, Attacks Player's Parent
Small
Random: Reggie Bush has a framed UCLA jersey in his house
Bruinsnation_small
Ben Ball Game Day Roundup: Season Starts Tonight

+ New FanPost All FanPosts >

SPONSORS


Managers

094_small Ajax

Bruinsnation_small Nestor

Menelaus2_small Menelaus

Arron_afflalo1_small Tydides

Brad_pitt_as_achilles_small Achilles

Small Meriones

Telemachus_small Telemachus

Small Odysseus

Blue_bellerophon_small Bellerophon

Authors

Images_small Ryan Rosenblatt

Official Partner of CBS Sports